In the past 20+ years there have been dozens of films based on video games. The sad fact is that not a single one of them has been a hit critically. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within sits as the highest rated film on Rotten Tomatoes with a 44% rating. Today we’re going to discuss the past, present, and future of video game films and what needs to happen for better adaptations.

-The Developers Need to Actually Care-

Right here is the biggest problem. Some game developers have little to no interest in the film adaptation that they license the rights and just take the money and run. These companies need to have a more vested interest in their intellectual property. As we saw in the 2000’s Uwe Boll built a career out of making video game films that were pretty abysmal (some of the RT scores for these films: 4%, 1%, 4%, 8%, and 4%). You’d think that once Uwe had made five films that were bombs they’d stop letting him take the reigns. Unfortunately he continued making more subpar video game films (mostly sequels to his previous adaptations) that made things worse. If only at some point an executive from any of these companies had looked at the products Boll crafted and said, “No thank you” to future films.

-Modern Games have Stronger Narratives-

In the 8-bit (and even 16-bit) era story wasn’t always the stronger point of a game. More often than not games were focused on being just a fun experience. Gaming has evolved to the point where many have such strong stories that non-gamers will watch Youtube Let’s Plays (we’ll talk about those at a later date) so they can enjoy the story without having to play the actual game. The Last of Us has been covered by multiple channels due to how emotionally engaging of a story the game has. There have been people who shed tears while playing this game. That is a perfect way to know a story is phenomenal.

-These Franchises Need a Kevin Feige-

Marvel Studios has become a force to be reckoned with at the box office in recent years. Producer Kevin Feige deserves a huge amount of credit for this success. Not only is he a smart businessman he loves the source material with all his heart. Companies like Naughty Dog need a person who has an intimate knowledge of their video games to step up as a producer. That way they can have a stronger voice in the crafting of a script, casting of actors, and all major behind the scenes decisions. Odds are this will lead to films worth watching.

-The Future is Already Brighter-

2016 may hopefully become the turning point for video game films. Two major releases include Warcraft and Assassin’s Creed. Both of these films have the potential to be great. With Warcraft not only does Blizzard Entertainment have a hand in the film they hired Duncan Jones to direct. So far Duncan Jones has proven himself to be a competent director with the superb Moon and criminally underrated Source Code. I highly doubt he’d sign up for a mediocre film. Now with Assassin’s Creed there’s not only a strong director at the helm, but a pretty high caliber cast. Michael Fassbender and Marion Cotillard are both thespians that have built a career on brilliant films. Fassbender is even working as a producer on the film. That leads me to believe he wants to have a real hand in the making of Assassin’s Creed instead of just collecting a paycheck. Will both/either of these films be a success? We’ll have to wait and see. So what are your thoughts on films based on video games? Have you enjoyed any of the previously made ones? I thought Need For Speed was dumb fun. Is there any game you’d like to see get the live action treatment? Personally, if they figured out how to make Metal Gear Solid work I’d be at the theatre with bells on. Are there any games you’d like to see get a 2nd chance at a film?

11 thoughts on “Are We About to See Good Films Based on Video Games?

  1. I think it’s a sign of the times. While I may not always agree with Hollywood’s philosophy on filmmaking, when it comes to adapting material they have got much better at it. You cited comic books as being a prime example and it couldn’t be more true. The movies definitely need a driving force behind them that has a mutual respect for the content being made. Having said that, I think there are quite a few video game adaptions that were really good but get overlooked when the argument comes up. Films like Silent Hill (not the abysmal sequel, the original). Silent Hill was a really good movie that had strong undercurrents pertaining to a woman’s right to choose. Granted, the team behind the film was top notch, so that probably made a huge difference, but it was still a really good movie.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I do appreciate that while Silent Hill didn’t do a direct adaptation of the game it got the atmosphere down perfect. And plus, Deborah Kara Unger is a fantastic actress who needs more work.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s